Learn to code by coding - try our free CS courses

HMAC and MACs – The Inner Workings of JWTs

HMACs and MACs are authentication codes and are often the backbone of JWT authentication systems. A Message Authentication Code (MAC) is a string of bits that depends on a secret key and is sent with a message to prove the message wasn’t tampered with. HMACs are a more strict version of MACs that offer additional security benefits.

Learn crypto, advance your career

In our “Practical Cryptography” course, you will learn the inner workings of popular cryptographic systems like Bitcoin, SSL, hard drive encryption, and more. Get started free, and write real cryptographic code using the Go programming language.

MAC – Message Authentication Code

MACs are exactly what they sound like; small codes that allow receivers of messages to know who the sender was (authentication). A MAC code is calculated by using a message and a secret key as inputs. Anyone who has a copy of that secret key can then verify that that code and message were created by someone with the same key.

MAC diagram

One way this is accomplished is by using a hash function, for instance, SHA-256. Simply put, a hash function takes an input and then returns an output, where:

  • The output is very unlikely to be the same for different inputs
  • The output is always the same for the same inputs
  • The output is not predictable – changing the input even slightly results in a seemingly random and large change to the output

Given this, a naive example of MAC generation by the sender could be:

message = 'my message here' macCode = sha256('thisIsASecretKey1234' + message) // send macCode and message
Code language: JavaScript (javascript)

Then the verification by the receiver would be:

// receive macCode and message if (macCode == sha256('thisIsASecretKey1234' + message)){ // verified! }
Code language: JavaScript (javascript)

Note that MACs don’t necessarily need to use a hash function, but a hash can be used as the “signing” mechanism.

HMAC – Hash-Based Message Authentication Code

An HMAC is a kind of MAC. All HMACs are MACs but not all MACs are HMACs. The main difference is that an HMAC uses two rounds of hashing instead of one (or none). Each round of hashing uses a section of the secret key. As a naive example:

sha256('thisIsASe' + sha256('cretKey1234' + 'my message here'))
Code language: JavaScript (javascript)

Which is a simplified version of the function given in RFC-2104.

Why use HMAC? Why do we need to hash twice?

With many hash functions, it’s possible to change the message (without knowing the key) and obtain another valid MAC. We call this a length extension attack. No known extension attacks are known against the current HMAC specification.

HMACs with JWTs

If you’ve ever implemented JWTs for authentication schemes within a web app, then you know that JWTs are wonderful for keeping track of who is who. A JWT (when using HMAC as the signing scheme) is basically just an HMAC message where the message data is a JSON object.

The interesting thing about the JWT system is that the sender and the receiver of the JWT are typically the same entity, that is, the webserver. Look at the following example:

  • User gives the server an username and password
  • Server verifies the username and password are correct
  • Server generates a JWT using HMAC:
hmacCode = sha256('thisIsASe' + sha256('cretKey1234' + '{"email":"[email protected]"}'))
Code language: JavaScript (javascript)
  • The server responds with the following (decoded) JWT:
header.{"email":"[email protected]"}.hmacCode
Code language: JavaScript (javascript)
  • User decides to update his/her profile picture by sending the following request:
PUT /users/profile_picture Authentication: Bearer header.{"email":"[email protected]"}.hmacCode {"new_picture": "http://linktopicture.com/mypic"}
Code language: JavaScript (javascript)
  • The server parses the JWT. The JWT says the user is [email protected]
  • The server verifies that the user really is Lane by validating the HMAC code. Only someone with access to the secret key ‘thisIsASecretKey1234’ could have made the HMAC code that corresponds to the ‘[email protected]’ message
  • If verification is successful, then the server updates Lane’s profile picture

If you feel that I missed anything important, or have any questions, feel free to contact me!

Have questions or feedback?

Follow and hit me up on Twitter @q_vault if you have any questions or comments. If I’ve made a mistake in the article, please let me know so I can get it corrected!

Related Articles